The Critical Case of Barnes v. Felix

Episode 58 February 19, 2025 00:39:34
The Critical Case of Barnes v. Felix
Guardian Mindset Podcast
The Critical Case of Barnes v. Felix

Feb 19 2025 | 00:39:34

/

Show Notes

In this episode, Attorney Eric Daigle dives into Barnes v. Felix, a crucial Supreme Court case with significant implications for law enforcement professionals. The case, currently under review after oral argument on January 22, 2025, addresses the use of deadly force, the totality of the circumstances standard, and the moment of threat doctrine. Daigle provides an in-depth legal breakdown, discusses how the ruling could reshape police training and policies, and offers practical takeaways for officers handling high-pressure situations.

Key Takeaways:

  1. Moment of Threat vs. Totality of Circumstances
Legal Framework & Historical Precedents Spilt Ruling Practical Takeaways for Law Enforcement

Final Thoughts:

 

This case is a stark reminder that use-of-force decisions don’t happen in isolation—they are shaped by everything leading up to the moment of action. Officers must be proactive in using sound tactics and making legally defensible decisions to ensure their actions hold up under scrutiny. As we await the Supreme Court’s ruling, now is the time for law enforcement professionals to reflect. Whether the Supreme Court rules in favor of the moment of threat doctrine or shifts toward a totality of the circumstances approach, one thing remains clear: agencies should take this case as an opportunity to evaluate their training programs, reinforce de-escalation strategies, and emphasize the importance of avoiding officer-created jeopardy.

Resources:

Other Episodes

Episode

December 13, 2021 00:16:46
Episode Cover

Qualified Immunity Part Two

Attorney Eric Daigle continues his review of qualified immunity and the impact of October’s SCOTUS decisions.

Listen

Episode 11

January 04, 2022 00:28:35
Episode Cover

Bystander Liability with Attorney Eric Atstupenas

At the 2021 Use of Force Summit, Attorney Eric Atstupenas sits down with Eric to discuss the current challenges facing law enforcement agencies related...

Listen

Episode 47

September 27, 2023 00:46:10
Episode Cover

The Intersection of Use of Force and Human Factors

Episode Summary:  Ever contemplated the complexity of decision-making in high-stress, life-changing moments? In this compelling episode, we delve deep into the multifaceted realm of...

Listen